Tuesday, April 17, 2018

Disappointment


I am disappointed. And that is a profound understatement.

In spite of my sometimes cynical, perhaps even pessimistic view of politics and the people who inhabit that sphere, somewhere within my very core I needed to believe that when the political leaders of Canada, Alberta and British Columbia met on Sunday that they would find a way to at least partially resolve their respective differences.  They didn't. All they appear to have done was to further entrench their positions as to whether or not the pipe line expansion would proceed. The three individuals went into the meeting with a clear agenda and they walked out with nothing changed. No compromise, no promise to continue to work together, no possible vision of a world where everyone would at least partially benefit - a world where harm would be limited. There are no indications that they even listened to each other. There were some clarifications of positions and on the part of the federal government there were clear indications of how far they were prepared to go - all of which, unfortunately were predictable.

I am most disappointed in the federal government as they, in their role of the senior government, had the greatest responsibility to demonstrate leadership. By drawing a very clear line in the sand, they have left no room for negotiation. This clear line is in part defined by how much money and political capital they are prepared to spend to ensure that the pipeline gets expanded.

In a country where there is (apparently) not enough money to ensure that all communities have access to safe drinking water or decent housing, where there are insufficient funds to provide universal day care, access to affordable proscribed medication, and a social safety net that actually works - the federal government has decided that we should give millions and millions (if not billions) of dollars to support the infrastructure of an international for-profit company (check out how much the value of their shares has increased since Sunday) ; the government has decided that in spite of a significant national debt and rising interest rates, that it will borrow even more money so that Kinder Morgan will be reassured that the pipeline will go through.

I, I confess, am somewhat conflicted over the issue of the pipeline expansion. I think that, depending on what you read, it is easy to become convinced that one's point of view is the only correct point of view. I think it is far too easy for us to only ever see one side of the story and to draw our own lines in the sand. I deeply wish that we could all have an open and non-antagonistic debate over the pros and cons, if we could look at all Canadians and determine what is best for all of us as a collective. However, I am not at all conflicted as to whether or not my taxes should be used to provide some sort of reassurances to a for-profit company - a company that if the pipeline does get expanded - will stand to make extraordinary profits. We have processes in Canada - there are traditions, regulations and laws. Kinder Morgan, while it may be frustrating to their investors, need to live within those traditions, regulations and laws. And that includes taking things to the Supreme Court to determine jurisdictional matters. For the Federal government to wave its big financial stick assuming that they can bully other parts of Canada into ignoring their rights to due process is wrong.

Anyone who has studied politics, history and economics understands that it has long been the responsibility of governments to support the capitalist; that it has always been the role of the ruling elite to ensure that those who control the "means of production" continue to do so. It has always been that way. But that does not mean that it always needs to be that way in the future. It is time for Canada to, at the very least, stop supporting companies who want to use our natural resources to make obscene levels of profits and at the same time want protection from some of the risks.

The debate over the use of carbon based fuels, who uses them and how they get to the consumer is a valid, perhaps critical debate. There can be no debate over whether or not we subsidize companies to do so.

Saturday, April 14, 2018

To Be or Not to Be (a Politician)


I never wanted to be a politician. I have never had the desire to be that much in the public eye, to be accountable for and to have to defend the decisions made by other people or to be publically derided by those who disagree with those decisions.  A politician is someone who has to pretend as if (1) they have all of the answers and (2) that they like listening to others prattle on with long winded self-interested stories. I know that no one, least of all me has all of the answers and I really dislike pretending that I like someone when I think they are a bit of a fool or worse.

None-the-less I can admire some politicians for their stick-to-it-ness.  Take for example Trudeau, Notley and Horgan - a strange collection/combination of politicians if there ever was one - who are meeting on Sunday to discuss what to do about the expansion of the Kinder Morgan pipeline. A federal Prime Minister who skates somewhere on the poorly defined ideological border of liberalism, progressive conservatism with the odd bit of new age socialism scattered about, is meeting with two NDP premiers who are on the diametrically opposite sides of the issue of whether or not the pipeline should be expanded. All three of the leaders are well and truly entrenched into their position, buttressed by their own statements made in the press and supported by the most vocal and demanding of their supporters. At this point in the discussion it is not clear to me as to whether or not any of the three leaders actually believes in the rhetoric that has been spouted about.  All three of the leaders have other issues to deal with. This issue, as important as it is to those folks living in Southern BC and along the coast, and as vital as it is to those Albertans who have spent their entire working lives on the roller coaster of bust and boom oil prices, may not the most important issue that any of the three governments need to deal with.

No matter what the three leaders talk about tomorrow, no matter what they finally agree or disagree about, at least one of them will be in a position of losing face, of appearing to "give into the opposition". At least one of them will need to leave the meeting saying "the  fight is not yet over".

Of course some might argue that Canada was built and has been strengthened by its capacity to find the middle road, to develop strategies based on consensus and compromise, of finding ways where the majority benefit and the minority do not lose. Those people would argue that leaders are not lessened when they look past the loudest of advocates to what people really need and want and address those issues, that one's status is increased, not decrease, when one works collaboratively with someone else.

However, it would appear to me the three leaders meeting tomorrow, although they might be really nice people in private and that they may in fact have a lot in common with each other, are not allowed to be themselves. That no matter how much they might want to find a solution that makes sense to most of the people, their political futures might lie in them being obstinate and inflexible.  

And that is why I could never be a politician.

Tuesday, April 10, 2018

Clever Folks at Kinder-Morgan


There is a part of me - perhaps an embarrassingly large part of me, that admires the political skill of Kinder-Morgan. Not that I agree with them but one has to admit they have placed themselves in a position where everyone else may lose and they are almost guaranteed to come out a winner.

Kinder-Morgan, in an ultimatum published yesterday,  have given the Federal government two month to resolve the provincial conflicts and all other jurisdictional issues over the proposed pipeline. If such a resolution is not possible, Kinder-Morgan state that they are prepared to withdraw from the project.

The Federal government, no matter what it does, will come out of the whole process looking at best as being incompetent and at worst as the wrong party to be running the country. If they force the pipeline through they run the risk of losing most of their seats in southern British Columbia; if they stop championing the expanded pipeline they lose any chance of any having Liberal seats in Alberta for the foreseeable future. Not only that, but if Alberta feels unsupported the province may withdraw from their carbon tax agreement with the Federal government, a cornerstone of the Liberal's environmental platform.

If the minority B.C. government do not fight the pipeline expansion with every tooth and nail that they have at their disposal they will lose the support of the B.C. Green party and thereby risk being voted out from government within a year of two of being elected. They therefore, must be prepared to deal with rising gas prices and the resultant ire from citizens who are less enthusiastic about resisting the pipeline. Of course if the pipeline does get built, people will say they did not fight hard enough and they will lose the next election. If the pipeline does not get built there will be enough people arguing that the NDP lost too many jobs because of the cancellation.

The Alberta government has clearly staked its position in the debate. They need the pipeline and will do anything they can to insure that the project is completed, including investing public funds in the pipeline. For the NDP party in Alberta, having the pipeline built is their only hope of being re-elected. The new conservative party in Alberta is champing at the bit, ready to be oil's best friend, to promise that they will "beat" the Federal government and scrape any of the environmental protections that the present government has created (e.g. carbon tax). Everyone in Alberta knows that it was not that long ago that another Alberta premier cut off the flow of oil to the eastern parts of Canada and forced the Canadian Government to back down.

Kinder-Morgan wins no matter what happens. If the Federal Liberals prevail to somehow manage both provinces and the Supreme Court (who surely at some point will be asked to rule on the constitutionality of some point or another) to allow the pipeline to be built - Kinder-Morgan will make billions of dollars over the life of the pipeline. If the pipeline is not expanded, Kinder-Morgan will be allowed to sue the Canadian Government for billions of dollars under a NAFTA agreement, not only for money already spent, but for money that they could have earned.

As I said, one can admire the political skills of the folks at Kinder-Morgan. They are guaranteed a financial win no matter what the outcome is, everyone else loses. The next time someone says that large business are at a disadvantage in our current political environment - perhaps they should think again.
  

Sunday, April 8, 2018

Who Pays for Free Choice?


I sometimes (actually most of the time) wonder if the government is far too involved in our lives. I need to believe that most adults are, most of the time, reasonable competent individuals who have the capacity to make decisions for themselves.  Then I read about some idiot who drinks far too much, gets into his car and causes some horrific accident that kills an entire family, or about the people who want to do an incredibly poorly conceived stunt copying someone else's poorly conceived seen on a YouTube video and kill themselves (e.g. car surfing), or for that matter deciding not to wear a seat belt. I then realize that there are some people who need to be protected from themselves, that there are some people who do not have the capacity to make reasonably safe decisions for. It is a sad statement but sometimes people need to be protected from their own stupid thoughts.

I personally do not care if people wear helmets when riding a motorcycle. In fact because I rode on a motorcycle in Quebec in the mid 1960s when helmets were not compulsory  I understand the desire to feel the wind. It is absolutely none of my business if someone wants to risk their lives. As long as the bike rider is capable of understanding that if their unprotected head hits the ground - they in all likelihood will either die or have significant brain injuries - let them do what they want to do. It is none of my business. Except....

It becomes my business when that helmetless rider is injured in an accident and my publically healthcare system becomes responsible for taking care of that person not just during the initial acute care period but perhaps for extended periods of time as the person lays there in a near coma like state. It becomes a legitimate concern of the State to try to insure that things that are preventable do not occur. It is appropriate for the State to insure that people, at least some of the time, are protected from their own selves.

Recently the Alberta government, following the lead of Manitoba and BC, have decided that Sikhs no longer have to wear a helmet while riding a motorbike.  The government did so because they were convinced that to force people from that particular community to wear a helmet would be a violation of their religious freedoms. I understand the problem, I am sure that alternatives to wearing a standard helmet were looked for and none found.  I am equally as sure that the prospect of charging Sikh bike riders for not wearing an helmet and then having those charges go through the court system - perhaps all the way to the Supreme Court was just too much. So the government gave in and took the easy way out. The change in the law affects very few people, the only ones who will complain are those who are conceived to be on the right side of the political spectrum and/or slightly racist and a small minority of voters (Sikhs) who may like the government a bit more than they did before. Of course for the hopefully small number of parents, spouses and children who may lose someone close to them because of an accident - they will not be happy.

None of my business - I really don't care . But I do think that included in that change of law sould have been the additional provision that any injuries resulting from not wearing an helmet would not be covered by the provincial health care system. I am all for people having free choice - I just do not want to have to pay for their stupid decisions.

Tuesday, April 3, 2018

Atlas Shrugged


As I have mentioned before - when I am weaving or spinning, I frequently have an audio book downloaded from the library onto my tablet. While the books that I chose are seldom noteworthy or sometimes even that interesting, it is nice to have someone read to me during the long winter afternoons. I can adjust the read back speed to one and a half times faster than normal and if, after the first thirty minutes,  the book is not interesting - I just delete it and go onto the next one. A week or so ago, on an weird impulse I downloaded Atlas Shrugged by Ayn Rand, a book I last read perhaps 45 or so years ago.

I remember, after I finished reading it, feeling somewhat uncomfortable. Uncomfortable because while I was perhaps just evolving into the first beginnings of socialist thought, I was also firmly locked into a belief that people should take responsibility for their own actions and that we should not (at least automatically) assume that someone else would solve our problems. Rand, through the voices of John Galt and his compatriots  preached a philosophy that suggests that the capitalist should be rewarded for their expertise and that anyone who takes from the system is a "looter". It is a seductive bit of sophistry. It is seductive because it promises that if one works hard - one will get a head in the world. Rand paints the alternatives (socialist thought) as dangerous and will cause people to become almost mindless selfish beings. As an example she paints much of Europe as a wasteland of unproductive people who are dependent upon the USA for support.

But such operational philosophies have a fundamental flaw. When I first read Atlas Shrugged I could not reconcile that flaw with my upbringing and somewhat firmly entrenched beliefs that hard work will make things better. I was uncomfortable because there was a profound disconnect between my upbringing  and my newly emerging philosophical, sociological and economic thinking, a disconnect that I could not resolve. Quite simply, there is no room in Rand's world for the state to support people who have needs beyond their capacity to provide for.  While it is true that in Rand's  world the skilled get richer, there is no explanation what happens to the sick, the old or the infirm.

This time around, I didn't manage to finish it. The endless pages of rants as to how unfair the present system is to capitalists, how wrong it is to have any sort of system that tries to manage some sort of equality of access, and the absolute disaster that is socialist thought just became too tiresome (it is much harder to skip pages on an audio book). I suspect that the book could have been cut by a third, and still have been just as interesting. There however, were two things about the narrative that either I had missed the first time or just been to overwhelmed to recognize, and that this time surprised me. One was the amount of partially suppressed but articulated sexual violence. Specifically during both
Henry Rearden's and Dagny Taggart's (male and female protagonists) private thoughts there are frequent suggestions as to sexual domination , and subjection through physical force. I suppose that in 1957 when it was written, such thoughts were deemed to be acceptable.

The second thing that surprised me, and one that I should have seen the first time around was that the collapse of the economic system only happened because  John Galt and his compatriots knowing and actively worked to destroy the system.  It is in fact a very clear example of absolute selfishness where the rich and powerful are prepared to destroy a system so that they can recreate a world that fits their needs, a world according to their singular definition of what is right. Atlas Shrugged provides a blueprint for how to disrupt  our economic system. Quite simply - make it work so poorly and inefficient through underfunding that it falls apart. Make sure that aid packages are misdirected, make sure that the rich and powerful make all of the decision (and then criticize them when they take more than their share) and ensure that working people know that there is no hope. In fact, Ayn Rand's world looks very much like a world's collapse designed by neoliberals. Her promise of a new world is a false promise - one that cannot ever exists even in the most optimistic visions of utopia.

I am no longer uncomfortable about the book, there is no disconnect. While I still clearly believe that we are all responsible for doing what is right and for working and contributing as much as one can, none of those ideals are contrary to the fundamental belief that we can and must take care of everyone.

Blog Archive

Followers